Why Islamic banks run accounts as an unrestricted Mudaraba (mutlaqa)

Why Islamic banks run accounts as an unrestricted Mudaraba (mutlaqa)

Unrestricted Mudaraba, known in Arabic as mudaraba mutlaqa, is a partnership in which one party supplies the capital and the other, the mudarib, manages it under an open mandate. The manager picks sectors, assets and counterparties on his own judgement, within Sharia and commercial custom. Profit is split at a ratio fixed in advance, while a financial loss falls on the capital provider and the manager loses only his effort.

How an unrestricted Mudaraba is formed

An unrestricted Mudaraba starts with an offer from the capital provider and an acceptance from the manager. The capital must be a known amount, normally in cash, and it must actually be handed over to the manager, who needs to be able to deal with it freely. A promise to invest later is not enough to start the partnership.

The word mutlaqa, as in Mudaraba mutlaqa, means unconditional: the contract states no sector, no asset and no counterparty. What it must state is the profit-sharing ratio, written as a percentage of profit such as 70:30 and never as a fixed sum or a percentage of capital. A clause giving the manager a guaranteed amount would turn the arrangement into a loan with a return attached.

Many jurists add that the contract should name its term or the way it ends, even where an open-ended account is allowed in practice. Such an open Mudaraba mandate without any exit rule leaves both sides unsure when profit is to be calculated and when capital may be taken back.

The freedom of an unrestricted Mudaraba, broad but not unlimited

Even without written restrictions, the mudarib remains bound by Sharia and by commercial custom. He may not finance an unlawful activity, sell on credit in an abnormal way or commit the fund to a deal that no prudent manager would accept.

Acts that still need the investor's consent

According to several schools, the manager may not lend the fund's money, give it away or hand it to a second mudarib without express permission. A clause such as act as you see fit widens his powers but does not automatically cover these acts.

The pooled fund at the heart of the banking model

In an Islamic bank, money from thousands of investment account holders is combined in one or more pools. Acting as mudarib, the bank places it in a range of financings, and each account receives a share of the overall result in proportion to its balance.

Commingling the bank's money with depositors' funds

The bank often invests its own equity and current account balances in the same pool. Gross income is then divided among these sources according to their average weight, before the agreed Mudaraba ratio is applied to the investors' portion.

Profit and loss in an unrestricted Mudaraba

In an unrestricted Mudaraba, profit exists only after the capital has been restored in full. If a pool starts with 100 million and ends the year with 104 million after costs, the profit is 4 million, and with a ratio of 70:30 the investors receive 2.8 million and the manager 1.2 million. Had the pool ended at 98 million, there would be no profit to share and investors would bear the 2 million loss.

Payments made during the term are provisional. They are settled against the final result when the account is liquidated, so that a manager who has taken early profit returns it if a later loss eats into capital. This is why a distribution in a good quarter does not prove that the year ended well.

The manager of an unrestricted Mudaraba is not left without risk. He receives nothing if no profit arises, and he loses the time and work he put in. A loss that comes from his misconduct, negligence or breach of the mandate, however, is charged to him personally, which is the only case where the mudarib answers for the capital.

Working out the profit due to investment accounts

Start from the income of the pool's assets, deduct permitted direct costs, isolate the share belonging to investment accounts, then the bank takes its mudarib share. The remainder is distributed using weightings that reflect both the amount and the term of each deposit.

Profit equalisation reserves

To avoid overly volatile returns, the bank may set aside a reserve from income before sharing and release it in weak years. The contract must provide for this, because it temporarily withholds part of the profit that belongs to investors.

Investment risk reserve: who owns it?

A second reserve, drawn only from the investors' share after the bank's portion has been deducted, is kept to absorb future losses. It belongs to account holders, not to the bank, and what happens to it when the pool closes must be spelt out.

Displaced commercial risk in plain terms

When the pool's return falls below competitors or market rates, the bank may give up part of its mudarib share to keep customers. It then absorbs a risk that, legally speaking, was never its own to bear.

Running an open-mandate account over time

Fresh money in an unrestricted Mudaraba does not always enter at the start. Banks that offer an unrestricted investment account usually accept deposits and withdrawals during the term and weigh each balance by the days it stayed in the pool. A deposit made two weeks before the closing date therefore earns a small fraction of what the same amount would have earned over the full period.

The manager bears his own running costs, such as staff, premises and systems. Under the AAOIFI approach, only expenses that arise directly from the investments themselves may be charged to the pool, while the mudarib's salary-type overheads stay with the bank. Check that the account terms say which direct costs are deducted before the ratio is applied.

Early withdrawal from an unrestricted investment account needs particular attention. Because profit is not known before the period closes, contracts often pay either a reduced share or no profit at all on money taken out ahead of time. Ask whether the bank sets a notice period and how it treats the share of the pool's assets that has to be sold to meet the request.

Why supervisors watch this smoothing closely

If returns always look stable, savers may come to believe their capital is guaranteed. Prudential authorities therefore require clear disclosure of reserves, of the distribution policy and of the fact that pool losses can reduce the principal.

Capital requirements and the share of risk the bank carries

Assets funded by unrestricted investment accounts do not, in principle, weigh on the bank's own capital. But if the bank routinely supports returns, the supervisor may attribute part of that risk to it when calculating its capital adequacy ratio.

What the account holder actually controls

The holder of an unrestricted account chooses neither the financings nor the sectors, relying instead on the bank's policy and its Sharia board. His levers are limited to the investment term, the choice among pools offered and the decision to withdraw.

Questions to ask before opening such an account

Ask for the sharing ratio applied, the history of returns, whether reserves exist and at what level, the conditions for early withdrawal and how a loss would be passed on. Final compliance of the product rests with the institution's Sharia board.

Reading the statements of an open Mudaraba mandate

The statement of an unrestricted investment account should show the opening balance, deposits, withdrawals, the weighted average balance and the profit credited, together with the ratio applied in that period. A pool-level report should add the asset mix, the gross income, the costs charged and the amounts moved to or from reserves.

A useful habit with any Mudaraba mutlaqa account is to compare the rate credited with the gross yield of the pool. A large gap in an unrestricted Mudaraba may reflect the mudarib share, reserves set aside or support given by the bank from its own share. None of these is wrong in itself, but each should be visible to the account holder and explained in the product documents.

Treat a past return from an unrestricted Mudaraba as information, not as a promise. Under this open Mudaraba mandate nobody may lawfully guarantee the capital or a minimum profit, and an advertisement that implies one deserves a written question to the institution before any money is committed.

Providers offering these services

  • Bank Muamalat Malaysia : Product disclosure sheet of the Mudarabah Unrestricted Investment Account (SURIA), showing profit sharing ratio, monthly payout and loss allocation.

See the full “Islamic finance contracts” section →