Why do Wakala sukuk dominate large issues?

Why do Wakala sukuk dominate large issues?

Wakala sukuk are certificates whose proceeds are entrusted to the issuer acting as investment agent, the wakil. On behalf of holders it manages a pool of compliant assets, usually leased property and Murabaha receivables, and passes the return on to them in exchange for a fee. Holders therefore bear the risk of the pool and, in practice, rely heavily on the credit of the issuer who runs it.

The documents behind a Wakala structure

A Wakala sukuk rests on a small set of contracts that holders should be able to identify. A master investment agency agreement appoints the issuer as wakil; an investment plan describes the eligible assets, the expected profit rate and the share of the pool that must remain in tangible form; and a purchase undertaking, discussed further below, governs the exit. The special purpose vehicle that issues the certificates holds all these rights on trust for investors.

The investment plan matters more than its modest length suggests. It is the document against which the agent's performance is measured, and it fixes the figure that distributions are measured against. A plan that gives the agent complete freedom over the portfolio leaves holders with little to enforce, whereas a precise plan, with sector limits and rating floors for counterparties, gives agency sukuk a clear benchmark.

An investment mandate rather than a sale

Here holders become neither buyers nor partner financiers: they appoint an agent, the wakil, to invest their money. The special purpose vehicle signs a management agreement with the issuer, which selects and administers the assets according to criteria set in advance.

Two-tier pay for the agent

The wakil first receives a fixed fee known at signing. If the pool earns more than the expected return promised to holders, the surplus often goes to it as an incentive fee, encouraging good management without shifting loss risk onto it.

Building the pool: leased assets and receivables

A typical pool combines real estate or equipment leased under Ijara with receivables from Murabaha or Tawarruq sales. This flexibility appeals to banks and states that lack enough unencumbered physical assets for a pure Ijara sukuk.

The tangible-asset threshold that keeps the paper tradable

As long as the tangible share, such as leased buildings, exceeds a minimum set by the Shariah board, often 51% and sometimes 30%, the certificate can be sold at market price. Below that it would mainly represent debt, transferable only at face value.

How Wakala certificates distribute income, with figures

Take an illustrative pool of 500 million with an expected return of 5% a year. The agent aims at distributions of 25 million. If the pool actually earns 27 million, the 2 million excess may be kept as the incentive fee. If it earns 23 million, holders receive 23 million unless the documents provide for an advance from the agent, which then has to be recovered from later income. The announced rate is a target for the plan, not a debt of the issuer. Because the agent's base fee does not depend on results, Wakala sukuk usually produce steadier distributions than profit-sharing structures.

The same pool shows how the tangible-asset threshold works. With a 51% requirement, at least 255 million of the 500 million must be in leased buildings, equipment or other physical assets, and the remaining 245 million may consist of Murabaha receivables. When rents are paid or a receivable matures, the cash is reinvested in new compliant assets rather than left idle, since idle cash carries no return and would also reduce the share of tangible assets. A drift below the threshold would turn the Wakala certificates into mostly debt, which can be traded only at face value.

What happens if a leased asset is destroyed?

The pool must be maintained at the required level throughout the term. If a building is lost or a contract matures, the agent must replace it with an equivalent asset; failing that, documents usually provide for early redemption of holders.

Asset substitution governed by the prospectus

Documents let the issuer swap certain assets for others of at least equal value, provided they are compliant and respect the tangible ratio. Investors should check who controls substitutions and how often the pool is valued.

The wakil guarantees neither capital nor profit

Like any agent, the wakil acts as a trustee: it is liable for losses only in case of misconduct, negligence or breach of mandate. It cannot legitimately guarantee holders either the expected return or repayment of capital.

Purchase undertaking and exercise price

At maturity the issuer usually undertakes to buy back the pool's assets. Practitioners debate the price: for the leased portion, a buy-back at face value is often accepted because the issuer acts as lessee; for the rest, several scholars require market value.

Reading the credit of the issuer behind agency sukuk

Why ratings follow the issuer

Because the issuer selects the assets, administers them and later buys them back, the practical risk of Wakala sukuk is close to the risk of the issuer itself. Rating agencies therefore start from the issuer's own rating and then look for specific weaknesses in the legal structure, such as limited rights over the assets. For investors this means that a high-quality pool alone does not make agency sukuk safe if the wakil is weak.

Dissolution events and governing law

The documents list the events that end the programme early: default by the issuer, loss of the tangible ratio, illegality or a decision that the structure is no longer Shariah-compliant. Many international Wakala sukuk programmes are written under English law with local courts addressing asset questions, which makes it important to read how disputes on ownership of the pool would be decided.

Liquidity at the end of the term

At maturity of Wakala sukuk the vehicle sells the pool to the issuer under the purchase undertaking, and the proceeds repay the Wakala certificates. If the issuer cannot fund the exercise price, holders are left with the underlying assets and whatever they can realise from them, which explains why investors look at the issuer's liquidity as well as its rating.

A structure used by states and the IsDB

The Islamic Development Bank funds much of its sukuk programme through Wakala structures, as do many Gulf and Asian sovereigns. Sovereign issuers outside the Muslim world have also chosen it for their debut issues.

A format suited to repeat programmes

An issuer can set up a master programme and then launch several tranches over the years, each backed by an identified pool. This standardisation lowers legal costs and speeds up issuance, an advantage for treasuries that borrow regularly.

The AAOIFI draft standard and genuine asset transfer

In 2023 AAOIFI published a draft sukuk standard stressing effective transfer of asset ownership to holders. It raised concern because many Wakala sukuk rely on beneficial rather than legal ownership of the underlying assets.

Wakala or Mudaraba sukuk: paid agent or partner

In a Mudaraba the manager is paid through a share of profit; in a Wakala it earns a fee independent of results. Wakala cash flows are therefore steadier, and rating agencies focus mainly on the strength of the issuer.

Questions to ask before buying Wakala sukuk

Comparing Wakala sukuk across issuers is easier with a fixed list of questions. The answers should be found in the prospectus; if one is missing, the arranger can be asked for written confirmation.

These questions apply equally to a sovereign Wakala structure and to a corporate one. They are general information and not personal advice.

Providers offering these services

  • CIMB Islamic : Islamic arm of the CIMB group, recognised as a leading sukuk house in Asia and active in Islamic investment banking.

See the full “Islamic investments” section →