Wa'd is a unilateral promise in which one person commits to another to perform a future act, such as buying or selling an asset, without any sale being concluded at the time of the undertaking. It differs from an offer because it creates no contract by itself, and from a guarantee because it does not transfer risk. Islamic banks use the wa'd to secure murabaha purchases, ijara endings, sukuk redemptions and currency hedges while the later sale remains a separate act.
The anatomy of a wa'd: who promises what, and until when
A well-formed wa'd names five things: the promisor, the beneficiary, the act promised, the event or date that triggers it, and its duration. If any of them is vague, a dispute is likely, because nobody can then tell whether the promise was kept. Banks therefore put the undertaking in a signed written document that states the asset, the price or the pricing formula, and the last day on which it can be exercised.
Until the beneficiary has acted on it, a pure wa'd leaves the promisor with room to reconsider. This is why the question of reliance matters so much in practice: once the beneficiary has bought stock, signed a supply contract or paid a deposit because of the promise, a withdrawal causes real harm and the Maliki-based opinion described below begins to apply.
Wa'd: a promise that comes before the contract
A wa'd transfers neither ownership nor price: it only announces that one party will act later. The promised sale, lease or exchange must be concluded through a separate instrument at the agreed time, with a fresh offer and a fresh acceptance.
Moral duty or legally enforceable commitment?
Most classical jurists saw a promise as a moral duty that a judge would not enforce. Part of the Maliki school makes it enforceable when the beneficiary has incurred costs in reliance on it. Contemporary Islamic finance relies heavily on that opinion.
Compensating actual loss, not lost profit
If the promisor withdraws without a valid excuse, he must in principle cover the loss actually suffered, for instance the gap between the cost of buying an asset and the price obtained on resale to a third party. Unrealised expected profit is generally not recoverable.
No fixed sum payable on withdrawal
Setting in advance an amount payable if the promisor walks away would turn the promise into a source of gain unrelated to any harm, which comes close to riba. Contracts instead provide for compensation based on the loss established, sometimes backed by a good-faith deposit.
How the loss behind a broken wa'd is measured
Take a bank that obtained a customer's promise to buy a machine, purchased it from the supplier and then saw the customer walk away. The bank's loss is the difference between what it paid and what it obtains when it resells the machine to someone else, plus documented costs such as storage or transport. Invoices, resale contracts and valuation reports provide the evidence; a rounded estimate does not.
If the resale price equals or exceeds the purchase price, nothing is owed, however disappointed the bank may be. Many institutions also hold a refundable good-faith deposit, often called hamish jiddiyya, against which the established loss is set off. Anything left over goes back to the customer, so that the deposit never becomes a penalty that outstrips the damage.
Unilateral wa'd, parallel promises and muwa'ada
A wa'd binds only one party. Two independent promises, each tied to a different event, are accepted by many Sharia boards. Muwa'ada, by contrast, means two reciprocal and binding promises over the same transaction, which raises more serious difficulties.
When cross-commitments turn into a forward sale
If buyer and seller both firmly commit to conclude a later exchange of currencies or gold at a price fixed today, the deal amounts to a forward sale. AAOIFI rejects such a binding muwa'ada where the exchange requires immediate delivery of both sides.
The originator's repurchase commitment in sukuk
In many sukuk, the originator promises to buy the assets back from the issuing vehicle at maturity or on default, which funds the redemption paid to holders. Conversely, the vehicle may promise to sell those assets so that an early redemption becomes possible.
Repurchase at face value: a limit set by AAOIFI
For ijara sukuk, repurchase at the issue price is accepted because the lessor remains owner of the leased assets. For musharaka, mudaraba or wakala sukuk, AAOIFI clarified in 2008 that the manager cannot promise a repurchase at face value, since that would guarantee the capital.
Drafting a wa'd that stands up: the points to include
A wa'd works only if it is kept apart from the contract it prepares. The sale, lease or exchange that follows must be agreed afresh, with its own offer, acceptance and delivery. A document that mixes the promise and the sale in the same clause invites the criticism that the transaction was concluded in advance, which is exactly what the promise form is meant to avoid.
- The identity of the promisor and the beneficiary, with the capacity in which each acts
- A precise description of the asset or currency and the quantity concerned
- The price, or a formula that yields a determinable price on the exercise date
- The period in which the promise can be exercised and how notice is given
- The method for establishing compensation if the promisor withdraws
Boards also look at whether the promise is binding on one side only. If the beneficiary is likewise bound, the structure begins to resemble the muwa'ada discussed above, with all the difficulties that follow.
The customer who orders the purchase in murabaha
Before buying a vehicle or goods, the bank obtains the customer's promise to acquire the item once the bank owns it. This promise is not a sale: the bank carries the risk of the asset between its acquisition and the signing of the murabaha itself.
Hedging a currency exposure through a promise
A company expecting a payment in dollars can obtain its bank's promise to sell it another currency at a set rate. Only the bank is bound; the company stays free. The exchange is concluded spot on the day the promise is exercised.
A promise to transfer the asset when the ijara ends
In a lease ending in ownership, the lessor promises to transfer the asset to the lessee at expiry, by token-price sale or gift. This promise sits in a separate document so that lease and transfer do not merge into one contract.
What to read in an undertaking before signing it
One should identify who promises, on what event, at what price and for how long, as well as how compensation is calculated. The link with the other contracts in the structure must be explicit. Approving the structure is a matter for the institution's Sharia board.
Frequent mistakes with a wa'd in practice
The first mistake is promising to sell an asset the promisor does not yet own or control. Whatever the wording, a firm sale of something not in possession runs into the prohibition on selling what one does not hold, and the promise is then only a way of disguising the sale. The second mistake is setting the repurchase price so that it always returns principal plus a fixed margin regardless of what the asset is worth.
A third error is treating a wa'd as a guarantee of performance by a third party. The promisor answers for his own act only. If a sukuk originator promises to buy back assets, the holders rely on his promise and on his solvency, which is a credit risk that investors should price rather than ignore. Finally, a wa'd that changes with every renewal, or is quietly rolled over without a new document, leaves the parties unable to prove what was agreed.
Questions to ask before relying on a wa'd
Whoever receives a promise as part of a financing should be able to answer a few simple questions. A treasury officer, a lawyer and the Sharia board each look at a different aspect, but all three need to see the same document in its final form, including annexes and any side letters.
- Is the promise given by one party only, or by both?
- What exactly happens if the promisor changes his mind after the beneficiary has spent money?
- Is the price fixed, or can it be determined objectively on the day of exercise?
- Does the promise stay separate from the sale it announces?
- Which court or arbitration rules decide a dispute about compensation?
A wa'd is valued because it is light: it commits without selling. That lightness disappears the moment it is drafted as a hidden contract, so the discipline lies in keeping it a promise.
