Islamic letters of credit: Wakala, Murabaha or Musharaka structures compared

Islamic Letters of Credit for Importers and Exporters: Wakala, Murabaha or Musharaka structures compared

Islamic Letters of Credit for Importers and Exporters are payment undertakings given by a bank to a foreign seller and backed by a Shariah-compliant contract, Wakala, Murabaha or Musharaka, which determines who owns the goods and how the bank is remunerated for its role. Like a conventional credit, the instrument pays against complying documents, but the funding is arranged through agency, resale or partnership rather than through an interest-bearing advance.

The parties and documents behind Islamic letters of credit

Four roles recur in every Islamic documentary credit, and Islamic letters of credit follow the same cast of parties as conventional ones. The applicant is the importer, the issuing bank gives the undertaking, an advising or confirming bank in the exporter's country passes it on, and the beneficiary is the foreign seller. Most Islamic letters of credit are issued subject to the ICC's Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits, known as UCP 600, which governs how documents are examined; the Shariah layer sits on top of those rules, not instead of them.

A typical presentation consists of a commercial invoice, a full set of bills of lading, a packing list, an insurance certificate and any certificate of origin or inspection the credit calls for. Because the bank may also need to prove ownership under the Murabaha or Musharaka structure, it often asks for the transport document to be issued to its own order. Importers who understand these papers handle Islamic letters of credit with fewer delays.

Sight or deferred payment

A sight credit pays the seller as soon as compliant documents are presented. A deferred credit pays at a later date. In an Islamic letter of credit the difference is not cosmetic: deferral on the importer's side is normally delivered through a Murabaha sale with a fixed price, whereas a plain deferral that increases the amount payable with time would be interest. That is why Islamic documentary credit is always tied to a specific underlying sale.

What a letter of credit brings to cross-border trade

A foreign seller may not know the buyer and fears shipping without being paid; the buyer fears paying without receiving goods. The bank steps in by promising payment against compliant documents, replacing personal trust with a bank undertaking.

Three structures, three ways to allocate risk

An Islamic bank cannot simply lend money to pay the supplier. It therefore chooses a contract: a plain agency if the importer pays, a purchase and resale if the bank finances, or a partnership if both share the cost of the goods.

Wakala when the importer has the funds

The importer deposits the full amount and appoints the bank as agent to open the letter of credit, examine documents and pay the seller. The bank earns a fixed agency fee that has nothing to do with the length of any credit period.

Why the fee must pay for a real service

The AAOIFI standard allows the bank to charge for opening, document checking and advising, because these are services. It forbids linking the fee to the time during which the bank advances money, since that would amount to interest.

What a Shariah-compliant letter of credit costs

The cost depends on the structure. Under Wakala the importer typically pays an opening fee, a document-handling fee and charges for amendments or advising, all fixed in advance. Under Murabaha the bank adds a profit margin to its purchase price, and the importer pays the resulting total at the agreed date. Under Musharaka the bank's return comes from its share of the resale proceeds.

Consider an invented example for comparison. An importer needs a shipment worth 120,000 euros. With Wakala the importer places the 120,000 euros with the bank and pays a flat service fee, for instance a few hundred euros. With Murabaha the bank pays the 120,000 euros to the seller and later resells for a fixed total such as 123,000 euros due in 120 days. The numbers are illustrative only, but they show why a Shariah-compliant letter of credit must be priced as a fee in one case and as a sale price in the other.

Neither structure allows a late payment charge to enlarge the bank's income. Where the contract contains a clause on delay, the amount is generally directed to charity, with the bank recovering only genuine out-of-pocket costs. Islamic letters of credit therefore avoid any mechanism that makes the bank's income grow simply because time passes.

Murabaha in an Islamic letter of credit when the bank finances the purchase

If the importer wants to pay later, the bank itself buys the goods from the foreign seller through the letter of credit. Once title documents are received, it resells the goods to its customer at a disclosed margin payable on a set date.

At what point does the bank become the owner?

The resale is valid only after the bank has acquired the goods and bears their risk, usually when the bill of lading is endorsed to it. If the customer signs the Murabaha before that step, the transaction loses its compliance.

Musharaka to share the import transaction

The importer contributes part of the price and the bank the rest, so both co-own the cargo. When the goods are sold, profit is split by an agreed ratio, while any loss is borne according to each party's capital contribution.

Variant: gradual buyout of the bank's share

In some import Musharaka deals, the customer buys out the bank's share step by step as it sells the stock. This suits distributors whose goods are sold in batches over several months rather than in a single resale.

Discrepancies and rejected documents in Islamic letters of credit

Documents are rejected for small mismatches: a shipment date after the latest permitted date, a goods description that differs from the credit, a missing signature or an inconsistent invoice amount. The bank notifies the beneficiary, who can correct the papers within the presentation period or ask the importer to waive the discrepancy.

The Islamic layer adds a question: who bears the goods when payment is refused? Under Murabaha the bank does not sell until it has acquired the goods and carries their risk, so the contract should state what happens if the customer declines to take delivery and whether the bank can recover its cost from the customer's earlier undertaking. A well-drafted Islamic letter of credit sets this out before the shipment sails, not after. Disputes over discrepancies are one of the most frequent practical issues with Islamic letters of credit.

On the exporter's side: being paid by an Islamic bank

An exporter receiving a letter of credit from an Islamic bank enjoys the same payment undertaking as with a conventional bank. It simply has to present compliant documents; the internal Sharia structure between the bank and the importer does not directly affect it.

Prefinancing exports without discounting

Instead of discounting the letter of credit it has received, an exporter can obtain Salam or Istisna'a from its bank to produce the goods, or a Murabaha on raw materials. Selling a receivable for a reduced price is generally still refused.

Prohibited goods and checks on the underlying trade

The bank must make sure the cargo includes no alcohol, pork, illicit weapons or goods destined for a prohibited activity. This check on the subject matter comes on top of the usual international sanctions and anti-money-laundering screening.

Choosing the right structure for your business

A company with cash on hand will prefer Wakala, the cheapest option. An importer that resells quickly will choose Murabaha for a fixed payment date. One that wants to share commercial risk will opt for Musharaka, after consulting the Sharia board.

Questions to ask before opening an Islamic letter of credit

The answers separate a genuine Shariah-compliant letter of credit from a conventional one with a new label. An importer who documents the replies in writing is better placed to compare offers from several banks, and exporters can ask the same questions about the issuing bank's structure when they receive an Islamic documentary credit. Clear answers make Islamic letters of credit easier to compare with conventional offers.

Providers offering these services

  • Habib Bank AG Zurich : Product page for the Sirat Islamic Letter of Credit (Sight), a Shariah-compliant import credit built on Wakala and Murabaha.

See the full “Islamic finance products” section →