Commodity Murabaha: managing bank liquidity through metals and palm oil

Commodity Murabaha: managing bank liquidity through metals and palm oil

Commodity Murabaha is a transaction in which a bank buys a traded commodity, usually a base metal, for spot payment and resells it to a counterparty at a mark-up payable later, so as to place or raise liquidity without an interest-bearing loan. It is the standard tool of Islamic treasuries for short interbank placements, and each Commodity Murabaha transaction depends on documented ownership of an identified lot of goods.

Who uses Commodity Murabaha and why treasuries rely on it

The main users of an Islamic interbank placement are Islamic banks and Islamic windows of conventional banks, along with the corporate clients whose deposits or financings are built on the same technique. The reason is practical: a bank with surplus cash needs somewhere to put it for a week, and a bank with a shortfall needs funds by the end of the day, yet neither can use an interest-bearing money market. A Commodity Murabaha transaction supplies a compliant substitute that settles in a single trading session.

Treasurers value it for speed and predictability. The mark-up is known at the moment of the deferred sale, the maturity is exactly as agreed, and the documentation is standard across counterparties. The trade-off is that the instrument is difficult to sell once placed, since the asset acquired is a trade receivable, so it suits cash that will not be needed before the due date.

A treasury placement between Islamic banks through Commodity Murabaha

Islamic banks can neither lend nor borrow overnight at interest on the money market. To place a surplus or cover a shortfall for a few days or months, they use deferred-payment sales of metal between themselves, documented under a master agreement.

Placing ten million for one week: a worked example

Bank A has a surplus of 10 million. It buys 10 million worth of copper from a broker, then resells it to Bank B for 10,008,000 payable in seven days. Bank B immediately sells the copper for cash and so obtains its liquidity.

Orders, confirmations and warrant numbers

Each step leaves a time-stamped record: purchase order, confirmation of ownership listing the lots and their warehouse, sale offer, acceptance, then any agency for resale. Standardised master agreements, such as those published by IIFM, govern this sequence and each party's responsibilities.

Copper, aluminium, nickel: why base metals?

These metals are standardised, stored in approved warehouses and identifiable by lot, which allows ownership to pass quickly. Gold and silver are excluded, because exchanging them for money requires immediate delivery on both sides, which is incompatible with deferred payment.

Pricing a Commodity Murabaha placement against interbank benchmarks

In the seven-day example above, the mark-up of 8,000 on 10 million equals 0.08 percent for the week, or roughly 4.2 percent if stretched to a year on a simple basis. That figure is purely illustrative. In practice, dealers quote the profit rate for each tenor by reference to an interbank benchmark, then convert it into a mark-up amount fixed in the contract.

Costs in an Islamic interbank placement are small but real. The broker charges a commission for supplying the metal, each side may pay a documentation fee under the master agreement, and tight settlement windows mean that a missed cut-off can push the trade to the next business day. Holidays differ between London, Kuala Lumpur and Gulf centres, so a placement must be scheduled with the calendars of every location involved.

Because the amount owed is fixed on day one, a Commodity Murabaha transaction offers no benefit if rates move before maturity. A lender cannot raise the mark-up, and a borrower cannot lower it unilaterally.

Bursa Suq Al-Sila: Malaysia's electronic platform for Commodity Murabaha

Set up by Bursa Malaysia in the late 2000s, this platform arranges commodity sales, mainly of crude palm oil, for Murabaha and Tawarruq transactions. It connects suppliers, banks and brokers and confirms every transfer of ownership electronically.

Multiple currencies and trades settled in minutes

Participants can deal in ringgit as well as foreign currencies, and the purchase, deferred sale and resale sequence is often completed within minutes. Institutions outside Malaysia access it through brokers, making it an alternative to the London route.

London brokers and LME warrants

Historically, most volume went through London-based brokers holding metal stocks backed by London Metal Exchange warrants. The same lot can be sold several times in one day to different banks, a point some Sharia auditors scrutinise closely.

Owning metal you never see

The buying bank does not take physical delivery: it receives a certificate allocating specific lots to its name. AAOIFI standards accept this constructive possession if the risk of loss genuinely passes to the bank and the lots are identified unambiguously.

Counterparty risk and operational controls in a Commodity Murabaha

Once the metal has been resold to the counterparty, the placing bank no longer holds goods; it holds a debt. If the counterparty fails to pay at maturity, the claim is a normal unsecured receivable unless collateral was agreed, and the creditor cannot add a fresh mark-up for the delay. Late-payment charges, where the contract has them, are paid to charity under the Sharia board's rules.

Banks therefore set credit limits for each commodity Murabaha placement, per counterparty and per tenor, and monitor them daily. Operational teams reconcile each leg: the broker's confirmation, the allocation certificate, the sale and the payment instruction. A mismatch between lots, amounts or dates is investigated before settlement, because an unrecorded step can invalidate the Sharia treatment of a placement worth many millions.

Broker failure is a separate concern in any Islamic interbank placement. If the broker cannot deliver the metal it has sold, the sequence collapses before the bank ever owns anything, which is why treasuries keep a panel of approved brokers and avoid concentrating all volume on one.

Fixed-return term deposits rely on the same Commodity Murabaha structure

To offer a customer a deposit with a return known in advance, the bank reverses the roles: the customer, acting through the bank as agent, buys metal for cash and then resells it to that same bank at a mark-up payable when the deposit matures.

Central banks and liquidity ratios

Lacking enough compliant securities, several monetary authorities have used commodity Murabaha operations to absorb or supply liquidity to Islamic banks. Because these receivables are hard to trade, they count poorly towards the buffers required by the Basel III liquidity rules.

Organised Tawarruq: why jurists remain divided

For the party reselling the metal, the operation amounts to organised Tawarruq, which the OIC International Islamic Fiqh Academy disapproved of in 2009. The AAOIFI standard allows it under conditions while advising against making it the main tool; others prefer Wakala or sukuk.

What a Sharia audit checks in these placements

The auditor checks that the purchase really precedes the resale, that the selling broker is not the final buyer, that the lots do not return to the original seller and that no unpaid maturity is rolled over with an extra mark-up added to the debt.

Why scholars question Commodity Murabaha, and how banks respond

Critics argue that the metal is a pretext: nobody wants it, the lots are never seen, and the resale occurs within minutes, so the operation looks like a loan with a conversion step. Defenders answer that ownership and risk genuinely pass at each stage, that the buyer is free to use the proceeds, and that the form follows the contract rules accepted by standard-setters.

Banks respond with controls meant to keep the trade a sale and not a mere formality. They bar the arrangement from being pre-agreed with the original seller, make sure the metal is not returned to the same broker by arrangement, and keep time-stamped evidence of each transfer. Some institutions also limit the share of treasury business that relies on it and seek other placements.

A reader who wants to evaluate a Commodity Murabaha should therefore ask less whether the contract exists and more whether every step was genuinely performed and recorded.

Checklist for a treasury team using Commodity Murabaha

Treasury teams that follow this order tend to avoid the commonest findings of a Sharia audit, and they can show regulators and investors that each Commodity Murabaha was a real sequence of trades.

See the full “Islamic finance products” section →