Power plant, motorway, hospital: how an Istisna sukuk funds construction

Power plant, motorway, hospital: how an Istisna sukuk funds construction

Istisna sukuk are certificates that finance the manufacture or construction of an ordered asset. Holders advance the building cost to a special purpose vehicle, which sells the finished asset to the end client at a fixed price payable on an agreed schedule. The difference between cost and price is the return, and it depends on the asset being delivered as specified.

Who does what in an Istisna structure

Four parties carry most of the weight in an Istisna structure. The special purpose vehicle issues the certificates and signs both contracts; the client, often a ministry or a state-owned utility, orders the asset and later pays the price; the contractor builds it; and an independent engineer certifies progress. A trustee holds the rights of investors and an agent bank usually runs the accounts, so that money released to the contractor can be traced to a stage of work.

In Istisna sukuk, funds are not paid to the contractor in a lump sum. Proceeds are placed in a segregated account and released in tranches against the engineer's certificates, each matching a defined milestone such as foundations, structure or commissioning. Cash waiting in the account is invested in short-term compliant instruments, and any income from them is dealt with according to the programme documents, which should state whether it belongs to holders or reduces the price.

Ordering an asset that does not exist yet

Istisna is an exception to the ban on selling what one does not own: the manufacturer undertakes to deliver a precisely described asset on a fixed date for a price set in the contract. The sukuk scales this contract up to a large infrastructure project.

The two contracts in a parallel Istisna

The holders' special purpose vehicle sells the future asset to the end client, for example a ministry, under a first Istisna. It then orders construction from a building contractor under a second Istisna, separate and not conditional on the first.

Worked example: a 400 million power plant

The contractor bills 400 million, paid in instalments over three years from the holders' funds. The vehicle sells the plant to the client for 460 million, settled in annual payments after delivery. The 60 million difference is the profit distributed to investors.

Why the price must be fixed at signing

Unlike a floating-rate construction loan, the Istisna price is known and cannot rise with the repayment period. Late payment by the client generates no extra income for holders; any penalties are paid to charity.

The price of an Istisna sukuk across time

The schedule explains much of the risk of Istisna certificates. Suppose a project costs 400 million, takes three years to build and is sold for 460 million, payable in five equal annual instalments of 92 million after delivery. During construction the client pays nothing, so holders receive no distribution from the sale unless the structure includes advance rent or another source of income. Their return of 60 million is earned only if the asset is completed and the client keeps to the schedule.

A delay changes the arithmetic without changing the contractual price. If delivery slips by a year, the profit is spread over a longer period and the equivalent yield for holders falls, which is why the penalty clause and a clear long-stop date matter. For a pure Istisna sukuk the price may be fixed, but the real return is only certain once the works are finished, accepted and the first instalment is paid. Construction sukuk therefore suit investors able to wait for the completion of the asset.

Contractor failure and the holders' exposure

Towards the client, the vehicle remains responsible for delivering a compliant asset. It passes this risk to the contractor through the second contract, but if the contractor fails, holders are exposed to cost overruns, which clearly sets the deal apart from a simple secured loan.

Penalty clause for late delivery

AAOIFI standards allow an Istisna to include a clause setting compensation per day or month of delay by the manufacturer, provided the delay is not due to force majeure. This clause protects holders against works that drag on.

Technical specifications and acceptance of the works

The contract describes the asset precisely enough to avoid gharar: floor areas, capacities, building codes, materials. An independent engineer monitors progress, approves each drawdown and certifies final acceptance before the price receivable starts to run.

Change orders during construction

If the client requests modifications, an amendment sets the corresponding extra price. The parties cannot agree an automatic revision linked to the cost of money; only a real, costed and accepted change to the asset can alter the amount due.

Construction and counterparty risks in construction sukuk

Protections taken from the contractor

Documents usually require the contractor to provide a performance bond or bank guarantee and to take out construction all-risks insurance. Part of each payment may be retained until final acceptance. These tools reduce, but do not remove, the loss from cost overruns or defective work, which still falls on the vehicle and therefore on the holders.

The client's payment risk

After delivery, in an Istisna structure, the price is a receivable from the client. For Istisna sukuk issued by or for a state entity, investors depend on that entity's capacity to pay on time; for a private developer they look at cash flows from the finished asset. Late-payment compensation cannot be kept by holders, so a delay always lowers their effective return.

Completion risk and early termination

If the works are abandoned or the contractor is replaced, the programme documents say what happens to funds already released and who bears the cost of finding another builder. In a severe case the Istisna structure is unwound, the client buys the work already completed at an agreed value and Istisna certificates are repaid from that sum, which may be less than their original capital.

A certificate that cannot trade at market price

Once funds have been paid to the contractor, holders mainly own a receivable from the client, payable after delivery. A debt can only be transferred at face value, so a pure Istisna sukuk is usually held to maturity by banks or funds.

The Istisna then Ijara combination

To make the certificate tradable, many structures keep the completed asset in the holders' ownership and lease it to the client on delivery. Advance rents may be collected during construction, then the Ijara phase turns the certificate into one backed by a real asset.

Advance rents: a regulated practice

Collecting rent before an asset is delivered is accepted only if those sums are treated as advance payments, adjusted if the asset is never delivered or arrives late. Sharia boards require this refund so that holders are not paid for use that never existed.

Which issuers and which projects?

These certificates suit governments, public authorities and infrastructure developers: energy, social housing, transport, airports. They require a solid technical file and a reliable contractor; most issues are placed with institutional investors in the Gulf and Asia.

Questions to ask before buying Istisna certificates

A short list helps to compare issues and to check that the Istisna sukuk really finances construction rather than disguising a loan. The answers must be in the prospectus; if not, the arranger can be asked to confirm them in writing.

These points on construction sukuk are general information and not a personal recommendation.

See the full “Islamic investments” section →