What Islamic investment funds actually hold, and what they cost

What Islamic investment funds actually hold, and what they cost

Islamic investment funds are collective investment vehicles that pool the money of many unitholders into assets screened under Sharia, supervised by a religious board, and that exclude prohibited sectors, excessive leverage and any return earned through interest.

Reading the documents of Islamic investment funds before subscribing

The prospectus and the key information document come first. Look for the name of the Sharia board and its members, the index or standard used to screen holdings, the exact thresholds applied and the policy for giving away impure income. Islamic investment funds worth considering publish all of this; a fund that only says it is "ethical" or "halal" without these details gives you nothing to verify.

The factsheet then adds numbers: the ongoing charges figure, the number of holdings, the largest positions, the sector split and the date of the last compliance review. Check that the fund domicile and legal form match what you expect, for example a regulated European structure sold to retail investors, because investor protections differ from one structure to another.

Finally, look at the share class. An accumulating class keeps dividends inside the fund, so purification is done by the manager. A distributing class pays dividends out, and the investor may then have to compute and donate the impure share personally. Both can be compliant, but the practical work differs, and it is worth knowing which one your Sharia-compliant funds use before the first dividend arrives.

Four families of Sharia-compatible funds

There are equity funds holding screened listed companies; Sukuk funds paying regular income; Islamic money-market funds placed in commodity Murabaha and short Sukuk; and property funds that collect Ijara rents.

Index fund or active management: two philosophies

An index fund tracks an Islamic index published by an index provider whose constituents are already screened. An active manager picks stocks within the compliant universe, which raises fees but allows companies considered borderline to be avoided.

Islamic money-market funds and their returns

Lacking interest-bearing deposits, these funds place cash in short-term commodity Murabaha with Islamic banks. Their returns therefore follow interbank profit rates, but they are never guaranteed and may vary slightly from one week to the next.

Why a fund cannot promise to return capital

Guaranteeing capital to the unitholder would turn the unit into an interest-bearing claim. Some so-called protected funds rely on a unilateral promise from an independent third party, a structure several Sharia boards accept and others reject; the prospectus should say so.

Risks specific to a Sharia-screened portfolio

Because conventional banks, insurers and heavily indebted groups are removed, Islamic equity funds usually lean towards technology, healthcare, industry and consumer goods, with little or no exposure to financials. In some years this tilt helps performance and in others it hurts, so Islamic equity funds should not be judged against a broad benchmark without remembering how different the sector mix is.

Sukuk funds, the other major category of halal funds, carry their own risks: issuer concentration, limited secondary-market trading and, for many issues, exposure to a small number of countries. Property funds can suspend or delay redemptions if buildings cannot be sold quickly, and currency risk appears in Islamic investment funds whenever the fund invests in a currency other than your own.

Screening companies by business activity

The first filter removes companies whose core business is prohibited: conventional banking, conventional insurance, alcohol, pork, gambling, tobacco or adult entertainment. A minor non-compliant activity is tolerated if it stays below an income threshold set by the methodology.

The 5% and 20% benchmarks used in Malaysia

The Securities Commission Malaysia method tolerates 5% of revenue from clearly prohibited activities, such as alcohol or interest, and 20% for mixed activities, such as hotels or renting property to tenants carrying on non-compliant business.

Leverage and cash ratios to respect

The second filter looks at financial structure: interest-bearing debt and cash held at interest must not exceed roughly one third of the company's value. Index providers measure this ratio against market capitalisation, while Malaysia uses total assets.

What happens when a company drops out of compliance?

If a holding breaches a threshold, the manager must sell it within a reasonable period set by the Sharia board. Gains realised after the non-compliance date are generally given to charity, while gains accrued before it remain with the fund.

What Islamic investment funds cost over the years

The fee of Islamic investment funds looks small but compounds over time. On a holding of 20,000 euros, an annual charge of 0.75% costs 150 euros each year, while 0.30% costs 60 euros, a gap of 90 euros before any market movement. With Sharia-compliant funds as with any others, over twenty years the difference grows well beyond the sum of the yearly amounts, because the money not paid in fees would also have been invested.

For index funds, compare the tracking difference, meaning how far the fund lagged its index over past years, instead of looking only at the headline charge. Periodic re-screening also forces trading when a company leaves the compliant list, and that turnover in halal funds generates dealing costs that appear in the annual report rather than in the advertised fee.

Purifying the dividends the fund receives

A compliant company may earn some interest on its cash. The fund calculates the matching share of each dividend, say 2%, and donates it to charity. Depending on the fund, the manager purifies centrally or leaves the calculation to the unitholder.

Wakala or Mudaraba: how the manager is paid

Under a Wakala mandate, the manager earns a fixed fee, often an annual percentage of assets, whether the fund gains or loses. Under Mudaraba, it receives an agreed share of profits and gets nothing if there is a loss, unless it was negligent.

An appointed and accountable Sharia adviser

In Malaysia, every Islamic fund must appoint a Sharia adviser registered with the regulator. The adviser approves the prospectus, the screening method and purification, then confirms each year in the fund report that management has remained compliant.

Comparing fees with a conventional fund

Screening, audits and the Sharia board add costs, so an Islamic equity fund often charges more than a comparable conventional index fund. Investors compare ongoing charges, entry fees and how often purification is carried out before subscribing.

Questions to put to the provider of Islamic investment funds

Some managers also publish a zakat figure per unit; if yours does not, ask whether the scholars advising the fund consider the market value of the units or only the zakatable share of the underlying companies to be the right base.

Is one of these Sharia-compliant funds right for your situation?

An Islamic equity fund suits money you can leave invested for several years, since prices can fall sharply before they recover. Money needed within months does not belong in Islamic investment funds invested in shares, but in a money-market fund or in an ordinary account. Regular monthly contributions smooth the entry price and spare you from guessing the right moment.

Be wary of any product presented as guaranteed and halal at the same time, because Islamic investment funds do not promise outcomes. A compliant fund shares in the results of its assets, so its value moves. Write down your investment horizon, the amount you could afford to see fall by a quarter, and the date you will next review the fund. A clear prospectus, a named board and transparent costs are the best signs that the structure is serious.

See the full “Islamic investments” section →