Retakaful explained: how does a Takaful operator pass on its largest risks?

Retakaful explained: how does a Takaful operator pass on its largest risks?

Retakaful is Islamic reinsurance: the participants' fund of a Takaful operator cedes part of its risks to a retakaful fund, financed by contributions donated under the Tabarru principle and managed by an operator paid separately. Unlike conventional reinsurance, the retakaful operator does not buy the risk for its own account; it administers a pool whose members compensate one another for large losses.

How a Retakaful arrangement is built

Three layers of contracts sit behind every Retakaful treaty. The first is the Takaful contract between participants and their operator. The second is the cession agreement, signed by the operator on behalf of the participants' fund. The third governs the retakaful fund itself, whose members agree to donate contributions and to indemnify one another. Each layer has its own accounts, and a Sharia board reviews the wording before the treaty is signed.

The practical sequence is straightforward. The cedant defines which portfolio it wants to protect, for example a group life scheme or a book of commercial property policies. It then asks one or several retakaful operators to quote, negotiates the treaty terms and pays the retakaful contribution from the participants' fund. When a covered loss occurs, the cedant files the claim and the retakaful fund reimburses its share.

Documentation matters more here than in a conventional treaty. The cedant should hold the Sharia approval of the template, the allocation rule for surpluses and the description of how the fee of the retakaful operator is calculated. Without these papers, an auditor cannot confirm that the cession respects the standard the cedant claims to follow.

Why a Takaful fund needs Retakaful cover

A fund with a few thousand participants cannot absorb on its own a factory fire, an earthquake or a cluster of deaths in a group scheme. Ceding part of these risks stabilises its results and limits reliance on the operator's interest-free loan.

The ceding fund, not the shareholder, is the insured

In Retakaful it is the participants' fund that cedes the risk and pays the reinsurance contribution. The operator acts on behalf of that fund; it does not reinsure its own balance sheet, since it does not carry the underwriting risk.

Contributions donated to a second common pool

The ceding funds of several operators pay their contributions as donations into a common retakaful fund. This fund compensates cedants hit by large losses, reproducing at operator level the solidarity that exists between individual participants.

A Sharia standard devoted to Islamic reinsurance

AAOIFI has adopted a specific standard on Islamic reinsurance, separate from the one on insurance. It requires, among other things, segregation of the retakaful fund from the operator's accounts, compliant investment of reserves and allocation of surpluses to cedants.

When the retakaful fund runs short

A retakaful fund can face a bad year in which claims exceed the contributions and reserves it holds. Because the members donate rather than sell protection for a premium, the shortfall cannot be recovered by charging cedants retroactively at will. The usual remedy is an interest-free loan, a Qard, granted by the retakaful operator's shareholders to the fund.

The loan is repaid only from future surpluses of that fund, never from the personal assets of the cedants. If the fund never recovers, the shareholders bear the loss of the advance. That rule shows why the capital and reputation of the retakaful operator matter to a cedant: the promise of payment rests on the pooled resources first and on the shareholders' loan second.

Reserves must be invested in instruments that the Sharia board accepts, such as sukuk, murabaha placements or screened equities. Holding the reserves in an interest-bearing deposit would taint the result and could disqualify the arrangement. Cedants are well advised to ask for the investment policy of the retakaful fund and for the split of the portfolio between liquid and longer-term holdings.

How a Retakaful operator is paid

As at the first level, the reinsurance operator earns Wakala fees deducted from ceded contributions, a Mudaraba share of investment returns, or both. It does not pocket the difference between contributions and claims.

Proportional and non-proportional treaties

Under quota share, the fund cedes, say, 40% of every risk and recovers 40% of every claim. Under excess of loss, the reinsurer pays only above a threshold, for example 2 million euros. Both techniques are used in Retakaful.

The question of reinsurance commission

In conventional reinsurance, the reinsurer pays the cedant a commission covering acquisition costs. In Retakaful, several Sharia boards accept it as a reimbursement of actual expenses; others prefer to build it into the calculation of the donated contribution.

Who receives the retakaful fund's surplus?

If the retakaful fund ends the year in surplus, it goes back to the ceding funds and, depending on their rules, may reach the end participants. A conventional reinsurer would keep this result for its shareholders: that is the essential difference.

Buying Retakaful cover: questions to put to the operator

Start with governance. Which Sharia board approved the treaty form, and has it reviewed the claims and surplus procedures as well as the contract text? A board that signs off only on the wording leaves gaps in day-to-day practice. Ask also for the latest Sharia audit report, or a summary of its findings.

Then turn to financial strength and speed. Rating agencies assess some retakaful operators; others rely on parent-company support. Check how long the operator takes to settle large claims, whether it requires collateral, and how it deals with disputes over cause of loss. A treaty with generous terms on paper is worth little if payment is slow.

Finally, clarify the scope of the cover. A treaty can exclude certain perils, apply annual aggregate limits or require reinstatement contributions after a large loss. Compare these provisions line by line against the portfolio you intend to protect. Where the retakaful operator itself cedes part of the risk onward, ask which entities receive it and whether they are Islamic or conventional.

Using a conventional reinsurer out of necessity

Global Retakaful capacity remains limited, especially for large industrial or catastrophe risks. Many Sharia boards therefore allow cession to conventional reinsurers on grounds of necessity (darura), while reducing the share ceded and the duration.

Conditions attached to a conventional cession

Boards usually require that available Islamic capacity be used first, that no interest be received on retained premium deposits and that the arrangement be reviewed every year. Some also ask for highly rated reinsurers to limit default risk.

Retakaful windows of major reinsurers

Several international reinsurers have opened Retakaful windows with separate funds and their own Sharia board. These structures bring capacity and actuarial expertise, but their compliance depends on genuine segregation of accounts and investments.

Where Retakaful business is concentrated

Activity is concentrated in Malaysia, including the Labuan centre, Bahrain, the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia. Regulators there set capital and solvency requirements, and the IFSB publishes guiding principles for the business at international level.

Limits and risks of Islamic reinsurance

Retakaful capacity is smaller than the conventional reinsurance market, so large or unusual risks can be hard to place. The few retakaful operators active in each region may quote similar terms, which reduces the cedant's ability to negotiate. Spreading a treaty over several participants lowers concentration but multiplies the number of agreements to monitor.

Opinions among Sharia boards also differ. A structure accepted by one board in the Gulf may be questioned by another in South-East Asia, for instance on the treatment of commission or on the use of conventional retrocession. Cedants that operate in several jurisdictions should secure written confirmation that the arrangement satisfies each relevant board.

Transparency is the last test. Retakaful reports should show the contributions received, claims paid, fees charged and surplus distributed, separately for the fund and for the operator. If these figures are blended into a single set of accounts, the cedant cannot verify that participants' money has been kept apart from shareholders' money.

Providers offering these services

See the full “Islamic finance products” section →